Game is too short

Repetitive gameplay

Duel mechanics frustrating

Linear gameplay limits exploration

Lack of meaningful replay value

Enemy AI too basic

Outdated graphics and lighting

Controller aim assist missing

Bullet registration issues

Skill tree lacks depth

More enemy variety needed

Arcade mode could be expanded

Story ends too abruptly

More environmental variety needed

Platforming mechanics are buggy

More meaningful collectibles

Difficulty spikes in duels

More narrative twists and depth

Expand skill system options

Improve replayability with new content

Positive Show original review

• Sentiments

  • I feel that the game is a masterclass in modern FPS design, showcasing exceptional quality and innovation.
  • I think the game oozes with personality, making it stand out and feel unique compared to other FPS games.
  • I find the game to be incredibly short, which is disappointing and limits the overall experience.
  • I appreciate that the game is arcade-y, allowing for replayability despite its short length.
  • I believe this is one of the best western games available on PC, highlighting its high quality and appeal.

Positive Show original review

• Sentiments

  • I find Call of Juarez to be one of the few Wild West shooters I would recommend, alongside Red Dead Redemption, which speaks highly of its quality.
  • I appreciate the creative approach of the game's narrative, where the levels change based on what the narrator has to say, adding a unique and humorous touch.
  • I enjoy the fast revolver action in Call of Juarez, which makes the gameplay exciting and engaging.
  • I find the inclusion of duels in the game to be a fun and immersive feature that enhances the Wild West experience.
  • I like the addition of bullet time mechanics, which adds a cinematic and dynamic element to the gameplay.
  • I appreciate the inclusion of an arcade mode, which provides an alternative and enjoyable way to experience the game.
  • I think Call of Juarez is a fun Wild West shooter overall, making it worth playing even for those who aren't typically interested in the Wild West genre.
  • I find the game's focus on hunting legendary outlaws like Jesse James and the Dalton Brothers to be an interesting and engaging premise.
  • I feel that the game's narrative structure, where the story is told by a bounty hunter, adds depth and personality to the experience.
  • I believe the game's ability to appeal to players who aren't very interested in Wild West themes is a testament to its broad appeal and quality.

Positive Show original review

• Sentiments

  • I appreciate the clever adaptation of Western tropes into a linear cover shooter, which adds a unique and engaging twist to the gameplay.
  • I find the level design to be well-crafted, allowing for different approaches while maintaining clarity on where to go next.
  • I enjoy the playful narrative, which adds a refreshing and entertaining element to the game.
  • I appreciate the lighthearted tone of the game, which stands out positively in a genre often dominated by darker themes.
  • I consider the overall experience to be dense and enjoyable, making it a satisfying playthrough.

Positive Show original review

• Sentiments

  • I think the game has a great art style, which adds to its visual appeal and overall experience.
  • I appreciate the excellent voice acting, which enhances the storytelling and immersion in the game.
  • I find the graphics to be impressive, contributing to the game's high-quality presentation.
  • I enjoy the gunplay, which feels smooth and satisfying, making combat engaging and fun.
  • I am impressed by the sound effects, which add depth and realism to the game's audio experience.
  • I think the AI is well-designed, making encounters with enemies feel dynamic and challenging.
  • I appreciate the pacing of the game, which keeps the experience balanced and enjoyable throughout.
  • I love the soundtrack, which complements the game's atmosphere and enhances the emotional impact.
  • I am pleased that the game runs smoothly on the STEAM DECK, ensuring a seamless gaming experience.
  • I value the built-in controller support, allowing for comfortable gameplay from the couch or TV without needing mods or workarounds.

Positive Show original review

• Sentiments

  • I found the western-themed first-person shooter (FPS) to have strong storytelling, which kept me engaged throughout the game.
  • I was pleasantly surprised by the twist at the end of the story, which added depth to the narrative.
  • The voice acting in the game is great, and it really brings the characters to life, making them feel more authentic.
  • I enjoyed the pistol duel mechanics, which are simple yet challenging, adding an interesting layer to the gameplay.
  • The arcade-style gameplay is interesting and provides a unique experience compared to other FPS games.
  • I felt the game was relatively short, which left me wanting more content and a longer playtime.
  • The game received an 8/10 rating, indicating a generally positive experience with some room for improvement.

Negative Show original review

• Sentiments

  • I feel that the game's combat system is frustrating because it forces me to rely on dual revolver gun blazing, as other combat paths like precise shooting and shotgun-play are ineffective due to blurred vision and difficulty in surviving close-range encounters.
  • I find the duels in this game to be even worse than those in RDR2, which I already consider lame, making the experience disappointing.
  • I am annoyed by the game's mechanic that makes bullets miss at a certain rate, even when enemies are directly under my crosshair, which feels unfair and poorly designed.
  • I think the game is unplayable with a controller due to the non-existent aim assist, which makes aiming extremely difficult and frustrating.
  • I am disappointed by the outdated engine, which results in washed-out graphics and cartoonish lighting, making it hard to distinguish enemies while they can see and hit me with miraculous accuracy.
  • I feel that the game gives the illusion of having three different combat paths, but in reality, it limits me to only one viable option, which is dual revolver gun blazing.
  • I find the enemy accuracy to be unrealistically high, which makes the gameplay feel unbalanced and unfair.
  • I think the game's visuals are outdated, with poor distinguishability due to the washed-out graphics and cartoonish lighting, which detracts from the overall experience.
  • I feel that the game's mechanics, such as the forced bullet miss rate and lack of aim assist, make it feel like a chore to play rather than an enjoyable experience.
  • I am frustrated by the game's lack of polish, as it combines outdated visuals with frustrating mechanics, making it feel like a poorly designed product.

Negative Show original review

• Sentiments

  • I found the story to be a wild ride of fun, which greatly enhanced my enjoyment of the game.
  • The gunplay felt responsive and satisfying, contributing positively to the overall experience.
  • I thought the art style looked great and helped sell the narrative, even though it might not appeal to everyone.
  • The music and voice acting were well done, adding to the immersive quality of the game.
  • The game came really close to being everything it wanted to be, which I found impressive.
  • The dueling mechanics were frustrating, as they made my hands and aim feel like they were drifting uncontrollably.
  • Dodging bullets during duels felt clumsy and lacked grace, which significantly detracted from my enjoyment.
  • The duels tanked my overall enjoyment of the game, despite other strong aspects.
  • I would pay twice as much for the game if there was an option to skip the duels, highlighting how much they impacted my experience.

Negative Show original review

• Sentiments

  • I find the arcade shooting gallery-style gameplay to be pretty fun, especially for short periods of time.
  • I feel frustrated that the game takes control over my camera constantly, making it impossible to know when I regain control, which disrupts the flow.
  • I struggle to see enemies clearly without using 'concentration mode,' which feels like a limitation.
  • I dislike being railroaded all the time; deviating from the path results in being sent back to the checkpoint, which feels restrictive and unfun.
  • I find it confusing and inconsistent that the control scheme in duels is totally different from the main game.
  • I find the narrator's constant commentary annoying; while it's the game's gimmick, it gets old very quickly, within about 20 minutes.

Negative Show original review

• Sentiments

  • I feel that the game is not worthy of the Call of Juarez name, as it lacks any meaningful connection to the series.
  • I believe the game is inferior in every way compared to its predecessors, including style, tone, story, and writing.
  • I think the mechanics of the game have been dumbed down, which significantly reduces its quality.
  • I sense that the game has a 'Ubisoft stink' all over it, implying a lack of originality and poor execution.
  • I consider this to be the worst Western game since Custer's Revenge, which is a strong criticism of its overall quality.

Negative Show original review

• Sentiments

  • I feel that the game is not really bad, but it has some noticeable flaws that detract from the overall experience.
  • I find the movement in the game to be clunky, which negatively impacts the gameplay.
  • I think the gunplay is unsatisfying, which makes the combat feel less enjoyable.
  • I believe the game shows its age, particularly in its mechanics and design.
  • I really enjoyed how the story was integrated into the gameplay, which added depth to the experience.
  • I feel that a remastered version could improve the game by polishing its less enjoyable aspects.